The
Conversion Cycle
by John Veltri, S.J.
from
Introduction Patterns Of Experience During A Lifetime During The First Week Of The Exercises The Pattern Within A Single Prayer Period Dynamic Model Of The Conversion Process Practical Applications Of The Conversion Cycle
As with most words we use to describe religious experiences, conversion is a word that can be imaged in many different ways. Some people image conversion as a profound awareness of God's presence which sets one on a new path of life; others image a profound sin-forgiveness experience; others image a startling event like the one which happened to Paul on the road to Damascus; others image a gradual redirection of one's life. Many use the word conversion for any profound redirection of one's consciousness. In this chapter, I include all these different ways. I understand that the maturing Christian adult on the spiritual journey becomes more integrated through many kinds of conversion. For such a person, the result of any type of conversion, whether on a religious, moral, affective, intellectual, or social level, is to expand one's horizon. The essential component of the many aspects of a Christian's conversion experiences is the freely-made decisions affecting one's life in Christ Jesus. Accompanying these decisions are shifts in a person's heart and consciousness. As an example of this, we can consider Peter's interior experiences. Like ourselves, he experienced different kinds of religious experiences from his initial attraction to Jesus, through an awareness of his own creaturehood and sinfulness, through a deeper insight into the mystery of Jesus' mission. Was Peter "converted" when he first met Jesus (Jn 1)? Or was he converted when he had the profound sin-call-creaturehood experience (Lk 5)? Or was it during that event when he was given profound insight (Mt 16:16)? Or was it when he experienced Jesus' forgiving love (Jn 21)? was it at Pentecost (Acts 2)? All these religious experiences have some connection with Peter's ongoing conversion toward deeper union with God and greater openness to the world. They were all conversions, producing a new horizon at different levels of his consciousness. Many of these individual events in Peter's life represent shifts in his consciousness and prepared him in different ways for the decision to surrender his worldview. In the midst of his ministry, he was converted to a new horizon, very different from the one that had carried him for so many years. By the end of his spiritual journey, Peter was called to surrender his image of creation (Acts 10), his image of how God acts in the world, and his image of God. Peter finally came to accept that God's Spirit could come to the Gentiles first, even before his Jewish sisters and brothers. As with Peter, our own different religious experiences -- experiences of acceptance, forgiveness, call, creaturehood, surrender, discipleship -- are also conversions in themselves and movements toward our more ultimate conversion. The movement along the spiritual journey is a movement through cycles of conversion. We need to be converted on many different levels of our consciousness. What is fundamental is not the phenomena of how the conversion takes place, but rather the interior decision made in freedom towards life in general or towards God. This decision may take place in more subtle, less dramatic ways, but nevertheless, it is a `metanoia'-- a change of heart, a fundamental change of a an attitude toward life, a new way of being, a re-birth. Usually, external events and the interior or subjective experiences accompanying them are like catalysts in the conversion process. The subjective or interior movements, which we call the "phenomena of the conversion experience," often motivate the decisions that are made as a result of the conversion process. At times, these interior movements are more subtle and less clearly perceived. At times, these interior movements may not be present at all. When they are evident, they are often discernible according to a more or less generalized pattern which occurs at different times during a person's life. Although the phenomena of the conversion experience are secondary, the understanding of their underlying patterns can be a helpful instrument in spiritual guidance. The pattern of the phenomena, underlying a dramatic conversion such as that of Paul, or underlying other types of conversion experiences one encounters on the spiritual journey, can be used to understand what is common in the phenomena of spiritual movements in general. In every experience of conversion, whether a dramatic event or whether an ongoing process, there are some common elements. These elements can be brought together as a point in time { · } or they can be strung out as series of points along a line { · · · · · · }. This is so because the elements of the conversion experience are organic with one aspect merging into the other aspect like a seedling that becomes a stem, which develops a branch, which begins to develop a bud, that opens into a leaf. One aspect merges into another over a period of time until the seedling has turned into a large tree. The oak tree is present in the acorn and the acorn in the oak tree. The generalized organic pattern of the conversion experience is somewhat predictable. As a result, the movements contained within "typical" conversion experiences can be used as a model to understand, to interpret and to judge the experiences that a prayer guide hears in many spiritual direction settings. In addition, there are many other practical applications of this model which are explored later in this chapter. With this in mind, let us take four different conversion-type experiences: 1) the experience of Paul; 2) the typical experience of a person during a lifetime of prayer; 3) the typical experience of a directee moving through the First Week; 4) the experience of a person during one prayer period.
Paul's Conversion Experience
Paul is on the road to Damascus and is overcome by a revelation of the
risen Lord Jesus. What happens in this unique event can be understood by
noting various aspects of the story of this experience and by considering
how Paul later reflects upon his own experience.
* * *
Patterns Of Experience During A Lifetime We can notice a similar pattern in prayer and life experiences over a longer period of time. When we first begin to lead a prayerful life and allow God to touch our heart, the sense of God's presence is experienced. God communicates personally and "speaks" to our heart. This felt presence of God, usually accompanied by a sense of love or wonder or mystery, is Consolation. As we continue to pray faithfully over some months or years, this prayer begins to dry up. Aridity is experienced; the felt presence of God disappears. Sometimes the reason for this is that we are distancing ourselves from God's Spirit, resisting a further call or challenge. Perhaps God's word is penetrating a deeper level of our psyche which resists the surfacing of some less-than-conscious emotions or memories. Distractions come. Uneasiness takes over. Temptations to give up the practice of praying emerge, and often we experience a lack of hope -- Desolation. If we continue to remain faithful to prayer and to this experience by expressing our real feelings to God, in time this Desolation is recognized as being a kind of helplessness or darkness through which we are being called to depend more deeply on God's initiatives. By continuing in trust and faith even when all the sweet sense of God's presence is gone, we are led, sooner or later, to a kind of enlightenment by God about our condition. In a loving way, God reveals the attachment or the self-centred desire for control in our life, or whatever has been blocking our openness to God's initiatives. What happens when such an enlightenment comes? We will likely experience a certain freedom from our bondage. It may be that we will finally be confronted by our own complicity with evil. It may be that the effects of some evil (e.g., violence, abuse, some form of being discounted, etc.) have been allowed to dominate our life. In time, we come to recognize how our love has been self-centred. This painful, yet hopeful sadness, is Consolation. Therefore, when we pay attention to our own spiritual experiences over the larger sweeps of our life, as well as those of other persons of faith, we can observe a pattern of conversion similar to the pattern experienced by Paul.
During The First Week Of The Exercises Let us now attempt a description of a hypothetical directee during the time of the First Week.3 Having come from a personal, warm, affirming encounter with God, he begins to discover that his prayer is drying up. He is distancing himself from something which he hardly recognizes. His prayer is not as easy as it was. He begins to talk about the fact that nothing is happening in prayer. As interview by interview progresses, he seems to be moving into a position of doubting his former experiences [315], [317]. He experiences turmoil leading to despair and a sense of being helpless. This experience is expressed graphically in the composition of the First Exercise [47]. There is a sense of not knowing where to go or what to do, and there is a sense of confusion while at the same time not perceiving its significance. Then some memory begins to surface -- a memory of some event, large or small, but nevertheless something which he perceives as a bad thing or evil. His confusion begins to surface into some more understandable focus like shame.4 Its meaning begins to emerge as he is surrounded by that shame and confusion of the Grace of the First Exercise. Gently the director encourages [7] him to stay with the desolate condition because she perceives it to be moving toward the Consolation of the Second Exercise as confusion gives way to sorrow. She also encourages him to dialogue with Jesus on the cross [53] and to wait for Jesus' saving activity. For the directee, darkness alternates with light as he perceives the experience to be unpleasant, yet meaningful at the same time. There is also a beginning of hope. Meanwhile, the director proposes the Third Exercise with its Triple Colloquy. At first, nothing seems to emerge out of this Third Exercise and yet, in hope and expectation, the directee keeps repeating it, asking, begging for the kind of enlightenment that he needs in order to be relieved from this condition. Meanwhile, there is a growing sense of sorrow and perhaps tears. Then something happens. The directee is given a profound sense of sin while at the same time he is given a profound sense of being forgiven and somewhat freed. At this moment, the directee "sees into" his condition in a way that is far beyond the work and prayer that he has been doing [330], [336]. Now he experiences his sin, and, at one and the same time, he experiences Jesus as saviour or lover, and, at the same time, he is given an insight into the depths of his sin. This phenomenon is often accompanied by a word which organizes for the directee a way of understanding and accepting the mystery of evil with which he has been struggling in such a helpless manner. Through this word, somehow the directee is able to accept his life as being so fully affected by sin -- almost like a hidden web of deceit that has touched everything, even the good choices in his life. This word -- be it a word like selfishness, or pride, or self-centredness, or seduction, or resentment, or whatever -- carries far more meaning for him than it sounds to someone not attuned to this experience. Something else happens too! At this moment, the directee perceives that though this sinfulness or disorder has been hidden somewhat from his consciousness, he has still been a conspirator in this evil. In this moment of enlightenment, he experiences that he is to blame and that, if it were not for the loving grace of Jesus which he is NOW experiencing, this same fault, would, by its own inertia, have its consequences in hell [65]. This, then, is a "typical" experience of a directee in the Call Mode as he moves through the First Week. We can visualize this dynamic as a wave-like movement in the diagram on the next page. The difficulty with this, as with most models, is that it represents the dynamic too smoothly. Nevertheless, this process does take place more often than one would expect theoretically without having directed many people through the Exercises journey. Sometimes, directees will receive the graces of the First Week less thematically than suggested in the following model. In those situations, the fruit of the First Week is received in a more confused way and yet with a very deep sense of freedom. Even though in practice it is helpful to use other models (consult Chapter Seven), this model continues to be the one experienced often enough by directees to serve as a basic way of understanding the spiritual movements of the First Week. In addition, this model is helpful for understanding spiritual movements in general. click here Figure 18: Dynamic Model Of First-Week Experience Throughout the Exercises journey, a similar cycle to this tends to keep repeating itself. God calls, one resists, one gets confused, one becomes helpless, then one asks for help. Finally one is given deeper understanding or "sees" something in a new way, and then one relates to Jesus in a a deeper way.
The Pattern Within A Single Prayer Period
Throughout one's whole life as a Christian, the cyclical pattern keeps
repeating itself. There are many conversions and mini-conversions. It is
a repetition of the paschal mystery of dying and rising in Christ. You
can discover these same elements that we have been noting even in one prayer
experience, though in a less dramatic way. I remember being at a group
prayer experience where the following took place:
The table below indicates how you can use the "moments" of the Conversion Cycle to set up thematic prayer patterns for the variety of time frames and situations of #1 and #2 above. The different time frames and needs of the groups or directees you encounter will determine the number of moments and choice of themes in your prayer pattern. The moments can be stretched or collapsed like an accordion or an elastic band and still follow the dynamic of the Conversion Cycle. To give you an idea how to use the table, two of the columns have been filled out. The exercise below the table will help you to complete the remaining columns. Another exercise will show how to use the table to create scriptural prayer patterns. Half-Day Column Imagine a half-day guided prayer program, beginning with an input presentation, followed by private meditative scriptural prayer, and then, by sharing of prayer experiences. In such a design for a few hours, you would have time for two sessions at most. So the table suggests that you first use the moment of Rediscovering God's Love and then some aspect of the moment of Paradox. Under each category are examples of scripture texts which indicate the kinds of themes you might choose. If this half-day were part of the Easter Season, the scripture texts used should harmonize with both the two themes above and Easter. For example, Jesus' appearance to Mary Magdalene (Jn 20:11-17) could easily be associated with the theme, Rediscovering God's Love. For the theme, Paradox, the Emmaus story (Lk 24:13-35) or Jesus' threefold forgiveness and call of Peter (Jn 21:15-25) may be very fitting. The Emmaus story shows the paradoxes of glory found through suffering. The story of Peter's being forgiven shows some key paradoxes -- how God can love sinners, in weakness there is strength, God chooses the ordinary to do the extraordinary, etc. Figure 19: Table Of Moments In The Conversion Cycle
Weekend (Wknd) Column Imagine a guided prayer program for a weekend held in a church building on Saturday and Sunday, 9:30 am through 5:30 pm, allowing a half-hour lunch break. The participants could bring a bag lunch on both days; they could have their own Sunday worship in the form of a closing ritual. Within this context, you might have time for five sessions, each with an input presentation followed by private meditative scriptural prayer and then, sharing of prayer experiences. After two sessions on Rediscovering God's Love, the table suggests you follow this with one session on Entering Our Brokenness/Resistance, then one session on Paradox, and then one on Reorientation/Harmony. Since this program is provided for people beginning to pray with the scriptures, the aspects to be chosen from the moment of Entering Our Brokenness/Resistance moment would be healing and being bound; usually they find healing issues less threatening to deal with than other aspects of brokenness. With a group that is used to scriptural prayer, you might focus on the other aspects of brokenness. Some material for your
study, reflection, discussion .....
The figure on the next page illustrates another way of representing the Four Moments of the Conversion Cycle and/or the cyclic rhythm of Consolation and Desolation.
1.
John C. Haughey, S.J., The Conspiracy Of God (New York: Doubleday,
1973), Chapter 4, "Contemporary Spiritualities And the Spirit," p.96ff.
2. Jacques Pasquier, "Experience and Conversion," The Way (April 1977), p.114ff. (return to text) 3. William A. Barry, S.J., "The Experience Of The First and Second Weeks of the Spiritual Exercises," Review for Religious, vol. 32 (1973), pp.102-109. The description in this article, as well as my own here, is primarily a reflection on the generalized experience of the notation-[20] Exercises journey. However, this model also illuminates the First-Week experience of directees in the notation-[19] journey. (return to text) 4. This is not the toxic shame that comes from "the secret" which typically results from various forms of abuse. Here the shame is one of embarrassment before love. I am ashamed that I have been loved so much, and yet, my response has been so little! (return to text) 5. A more technical name for dynamic model is `heuristic structure.' The adjective `heuristic' is derived from a Greek word meaning "to discover." When we apply a dynamic model or heuristic structure to a portion of a person's inner journey, we have an instrument to help us understand and discover the meaning of that person's experience -- where it has come from and where it is going. (return to text) 6. This four-part structure with similar headings was originally suggested in 1989 by Elizabeth Cleary, C.S.B., as a useful framework for shorter directed retreats. Later I realized the connection between this framework and the Conversion Cycle. (return to text) 7.The Week Of Directed Prayer In A Church Setting is a way of making a directed retreat in the midst of daily living. It is such a simple structure that it can easily be used in a parish, school, university, or business office. Consult the Appendices of this manual for a description of this process. (return to text) 8. A spiritual guide can use this cycle as a way of discovering the "next little step" a directee is likely to need in order to move forward with prayer. It helps in focusing the forward movement already taking place in the directee's subjective process. (return to text) 9.
In order to help you with this exercise, you might want to use the following
suggestions. Below are useful scripture texts for developing such a prayer
pattern. You can rearrange them to set up your prayer pattern. You might
want to put three or four choices under different thematic categories which
harmonize with the dynamic and sequence of the moments/aspects of the Conversion
Cycle. Following the list of scripture texts, I have placed, in random
order, thematic categories which you might want to use for this exercise:
Thematic categories in random order for use in this exercise: Deep awareness of our need for God. |